How to spot a car scam

By the OnlyCars teamUpdated October 1, 20266 min read
A hand holding a phone with an unexpected text from an unknown number, about to delete it and report it as junk

Most car scams follow a handful of scripts. Once you know them, they're easy to spot, and the fix is almost always the same: don't pay for a car you haven't seen, and don't pay anyone you haven't met.

The short versionNever pay a deposit to hold a car, never wire money, never pay an 'escrow' or 'shipping' company the seller picked, and never give a code that was texted to you. See the car, see the title, meet at a bank.

The price that's too good

A clean, low-mileage car at two-thirds of what every other one costs is the bait. The story that follows explains why it's cheap: a divorce, a deployment, a move abroad, a death in the family. The story is there to make you hurry.

What to do insteadCompare the price with the market line on the listing and with similar cars nearby. If it's far below, treat it as a scam until you've seen the car in person.

The deposit to hold it

"Three other people want it, send $500 to hold it and I'll take it off the market." A real seller will take the first person who shows up with the money. A scammer wants the deposit and disappears.

The same goes for gift cards, Zelle, Venmo, Cash App, crypto or a wire "to prove you're serious". None of those can be reversed, which is exactly why they're asked for.

Shipping, escrow and the seller who can't meet

The seller is overseas, on a base, or working an oil rig, so the car is "with a shipping company" that will deliver it with a five-day return window once you pay. The shipping or escrow company is a website the scammer built last week.

Real escrow is rare and you choose itIf you ever use escrow, you pick the company, you check it's licensed in your state, and you type the address yourself. Never follow a link the seller sent.

The verification code trick

"I've had fake buyers, can you prove you're real? I'll text you a code, just read it back to me." That code is from Google, your bank or a phone company, sent to your number. Reading it back hands the scammer an account in your name.

No real seller needs a code from you. OnlyCars never asks for one in a chat either.

Title and paperwork red flags

The name on the title isn't the seller's ("I'm selling it for my cousin"), the title is "at the bank" or "in the mail", the VIN on the paperwork doesn't match the dashboard, or the seller won't let you run the VIN. Each of these can be innocent; together they aren't.

CurbstonersSomeone selling several cars "for friends" is usually an unlicensed dealer flipping auction cars with hidden problems. Ask for the title in their name and check the seller's other listings.

The rules that stop almost every scam

0 of 6 ready

General information, not legal advice. If you've been scammed, report it to your local police and to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov.

Keep reading

All buying guides