Fake cashier's checks are a well-known scam against private sellers, and they can look perfect. Here's how to make sure the money is real before you sign the title or hand over the keys.
The safest way: meet at the buyer's bank
Ask the buyer to meet you at their bank. The teller issues the cashier's check while you watch, or makes a transfer to your account that you can check before you sign. Many banks have a notary too, which helps if your state wants the title signature notarized (North Carolina does).
If the buyer brings a cashier's check
- Don't call the phone number printed on the check. A fake check can carry a fake number that goes to the scammer.
- Look up the issuing bank's number yourself, on the bank's own website, and call to confirm the check number, the amount and the name it's made out to.
- Better still, go to a branch of the issuing bank together and ask them to confirm it or cash it.
- Don't sign anything until you're sure.
"It's in my account" isn't the same as "it cleared"
Money from a check can show up in your account before the check has actually cleared. If the check turns out to be fake, the bank takes the money back, sometimes days later. Ask your bank when the money is really yours.
Other ways to get paid
- A screenshot or an email saying the money was sent proves nothing. Check your own account, in your bank's app or with a teller.
- Personal checks can bounce days later.
- Payment apps have limits that invite "I'll send the rest later", and some payments can be disputed after the fact.
- Cash is fine if a teller counts it and you deposit it right there. Don't carry it around.
Red flags
- A check for more than the price, and a request to send back the difference
- A buyer who can't meet, sends a "shipping agent", or wants to buy without seeing the car
- Pressure to finish today, after the banks have closed
- Someone asking for a code that was texted to you
OnlyCars never holds money for a sale and never asks you to pay or get paid through us. Anyone who says otherwise isn't us. More in our guide: Paying for a private-party car safely.